How much does this saving cost?

Halifax cardiologist Dr. Gabrielle Horne has had a $1.4 million damage award downgraded to $800,000.

In 2002, Dr. Horne, who was a rising medical star, had her hospital privileges reduced after a dispute with a hospital director of the former Capital District Health Authority.

Fourteen years later, in July 2016, after a 33-day trial into administrative bad faith a jury awarded her $1.4 million. It was the largest such award in Canada for damages to reputation and career.

The health authority appealed the award. So did Dr. Horne.

The health authority may feel they saved $600,000 with the decision of the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal, but at what cost? How much more was spent on lawyers for this appeal? How much staff and executive time was eaten up by this? And more critically, how much has this cost Nova Scotia and the Nova Scotia Health Authority’s reputation?

As we try to recruit new doctors what does the appeal say to prospective physicians about how we value and respect medical professionals?

Dr. Horne has still prevailed. It took her 14 years of fighting an unsympathetic system and she won. Two years later, she may have less money coming from the NSHA, but the court hasn’t questioned the facts: she was wronged!

The message is simple: this is a health regime that doesn’t value doctors. Of all the places in the world to practice medicine, why would a doctor choose to come to work among an executive class who won’t admit a wrong and will use the weight of the public purse against them? The only hope to salvaging the province’s and NSHA’s reputation is for a change at the top.

How much as this saving cost us?


A Post Script: This article in The Chronicle Herald tells us how much the lawsuit cost Dr. Horne.

It’s a safe bet that the corporate costs for Capital Health and NSHA were far greater. Thinking about the higher costs of government actions, it wouldn’t be surprising if the NSHA/Capital Health legal costs were between $2-$3 million. Put another way, that could buy several mid-range or one top-of-the-line MRI machine. Or it could have paid the salary of a family physician for eight-to-12 years.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to How much does this saving cost?

  1. ausca says:

    After reading the CBC article on this I felt exactly the same way.

    All that seems to have happened here is that the NSHA clawed back some of Dr Horne’s award, and some lawyers made quite a bit of cash from the whole sorry affair. I’m frankly concerned that Dr Horne might see this as the last straw and take her scarce skills elsewhere. I don’t know if I would put up with being treated this way if I were a top cardiologist, in demand almost everywhere.

  2. Bubbie says:

    Yes it is a shame that this, a top notch doctor, is being treated this way. This province is treating the whole medical community pretty shabby. There are twenty pages of the Auditor General’s report that shows bureaucrats earning salaries $100,000 dollars, many more over $200,000, totalling close to $100,000,000 for just talking about the Health Care System. Probably some of the bureaucrats are paid to find ways to prevent settlements like Dr. Horne. It is shameful that taxpayers pay so much for such little return and are doing nothing to make the system better.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s